Mining in Catanduanes: What is your stand?

Dave's picture
I am in favor of mining on Catanduanes
5% (9 votes)
I am NOT in favor of mining on Catanduanes
93% (153 votes)
I am undecided about mining on Catanduanes
1% (2 votes)
Total votes: 164

Coal Mining

emlasy's picture

Mayong maidudulot na maganda ang pagmimina. Madala na tayo sa mga nangyari sa ating mahal na probinsya. Matuto na tayo sa ating experience ng magkaroon ng logging sa ating probinsya. Nakinabang ba ang ating probinsya. Wag na nating sirain ang ating kalikasan. No to mining. No to logging.

ORAGON opposes mining

sarge's picture

PRESS STATEMENT

The Organization of Regional Advocates for Good Governance Onward Nation-Building (ORAGON) supports the call to oppose a plan. to extract coal worth P6.2 billion in the province, because it will destroy the lives of Catandunganons and in extreme case, erase the small island province of Catanduanes from the map. Oragon is a non-government multi-sectoral organization advocating good governance, sustainable regional development and autonomy for Bicol Region

The plan is contrary to the concept and vision of sustainable development.

According to experts, mining destroys forest cover and biodiversity, causes flooding, and pollutes waterways. Moreover, disturbance of the ground surface and forested areas during mining operations would increase soil erosion and cause flooding in the surrounding areas. Mine tailings would also endanger waterways and the sea. Coal mining would also leave the forests open to massive exploitation from kaingeros, “farm-and-run” settlers and illegal loggers, which would result in the loss of forest cover capable of absorbing 8.7 million tons of carbon dioxide.

Sources say reveal that the planned coal production of 1.5 million metric tons in five years would earn the operator P6.2 billion in gross revenues. Local governments are expected to get P9 million in taxes and provide employment in the amount of P10 million.

The mining activity would benefit only the operators but damage from landslides, flooding and reduced water flow to rivers would cost more than whatever local government units would get from mining.

Records show that the Department of Energy awarded 7,000 hectares of land in the province to Monte Oro Resources Energy Inc. in 2005 for coal exploration without public consultation. The new plan will exploit additional 8,000 hectares of the remaining 60,000 hectares forest cover of the province.

In a letter addressed to Energy Secretary Angelo Reyes, Oragon appealed to stop all mining operations in the province. Irresponsible mining activities and blatant exploitation of natural resources would cause more tragedies to the people of Catanduanes. It also urged Reyes to respect the sentiments of local government, religious groups, non government organizations and the people of the province.

Instead, Oragon urged that the Energy Department to explore alternative sources of energy that are abundant in Catanduanes such as wind turbines and wave.

Currently, mini-hydro power plants are being operated in Hitoma, in the town of Caramoran.

no to mining in catanduanes

cutiepie's picture

i admire people who oppose mining in catanduanes. aba dapat lang na ioppose natin yan kc mawawala sa mapa ang catanduanes pg ngkaroon ng mining activity d2. tingnan natin ang long term impact ng mining sa isang lugar hindi lang un short term benefits. mgresearch naman kau mr macera and mr del rosario if ano ang nangyari sa mga mining areas d2 sa pilipinas. may maganda bang nangyari sa kanilang lugar? yumaman ba sila? hindi! infact lalo silang namulubi at nasira pa kalikasan nila.

Macenas tabi

Jorge O. Macenas's picture

cutiepie, I will appreciate very much if you can spell my surname correctly. Spelling pa sana isakit na, maga hurit pa?

Ikaw tabi anong research an piga basehan mo? Kahehelak man kun sige man sana torakpa nin torakpa pero kurang kaaraman sa isyu.

More than twenty years tabi ako sa industry. I participated in the project feasiblity study of coal prospect in Payo way back in the 80's. Kung sa akong pag adar nin coal prospect sa Payo makaraot according to your wild imagination, ako tabi ang mapunta sa enotan para mag lead sa diyalogo na kontrahon yan. Kung ga malasakit ka mas lalo na ako por dahil harane an baray ko sa area nin coal prospect. Less than five linear kilometers tabi.

Madyag pa open your mind, take out your biases asin mag dongog na sana sa public consultation para masabotan tabi kun ano talaga an tunay na estado nin proyektong yan.

Next time, could you please focus on the issue not the name and not the person.

PROPOSED MINING

I definitely agree with the stand of ORAGON. I have been around for 52 years and only during this administration kakalkalin ang ating mahal na probinsya... they don't care an iota on what will happen to our province because they have nice houses to go to far from catanduanes, in case nature will get back at us for our (their) abuse to our environment, and for what reason? GREED!!!!.... Be aware of what our local officials will do regarding this..... mga kababayan, isipon nato ang long term effect ninto sa ato gabos.... we only have one mother earth.....

Saro duwa tolo,dakul man pyan kita

bulod's picture

Majority win ika nga,,pro kng ung mga nka tukaw sa pwesto mag patapal ning kwarta daing luwas maski mag abot pa kita ning milyones n bkung pabor,ano daw Manong Dave..

" don't change the mountain let the mountain change you " bulod

3 votes

eman's picture

sain daw jan so tolong nagboto na gapabor sa mina ta dae lamang gapamidbid buda magsaysay ta kung tangata pabor sinda siguro nasupog sa mga pandok ninda.harharhar

oi hapot lang ta kung tangata pabor kamo baad lamang maguyon na ako apat na kita pagnagkataon...

....3 votes....

toracks's picture

bwahahaha.... ice bha..a.a.a.ahhh...
anu daw talaga ta 3 sanang boto... su saro baga nagpabisto na...
seaman da pati mons tots... hamak pa yan... agdahon ko daw yon mag karigos sa dagat....
su duwa baad aduman pa sa ki vicki belo... gapagayon ta grabing imo...
mabakar pati un nin hayden camera... miing batery di oring...
toracks

HABO KI ARA MINA

vicVic caMu's picture

oh! pang 115 ako sa dai favor sa mina sa Catanduanes.. Kasaday na ngani ning satong probinsya, mamina pa... mahuhuwa ang kabukidan...pollution, nature, health, . GABOS APEKTADO... iyo magenerate ning income, trabaho pero, tempotary lng ini.. pagnatapos ang mina, sain kita pupuloton?

MGA NASA PUESTO, MAG ISIP ISIP TABI KAMU! HARION MAN ANG KABUANGAN...

Dai ako pabor sa mining ta

Milms's picture

Dai ako pabor sa mining ta mala.....kasaday n ngani kan satong isla na galataw-lataw sa tubig titirahon pa nin mining. Eh pan o kun mahullbot an satong isla di malubog na yan....mabubura na kita sa mapa...ha ha ha(just kidding)! Seryoso na ini.........an magiging resulta pan o kan mining na ini sato............kauyagan kan satong environment! Ata gadiit na gadiit an satuyang forest dahil sa illegal logging boda sa rapado nin bagyo....dadagdagan pa kaining mina. Dai na kamo naherak sa probinsiya ta????

Diit lang ang makinabang kan mining na ini....pero gabos kitang taga Catanduanes ma-suffer sa magiging resulta kaini.

Sa mga kinauukulan....mag-isip-isip kamo......!

Ting Sorreda-Funke
http://www.philippinischer-kulturkreis.de
http://www.friendster.com/tingsorreda

+__+ Kamomondo man lamang na

+__+ Kamomondo man lamang na isipin ikan pa man paran pabor maske painano, mai lamang naiisp yan kahahantungan ninyan banwa nato pag nadagos yan. Malubog yan kadiging banwa na yan kung miminahan pa. ata saday na ngani an.

kamomondo

demokratico kita cris kaya sige lang maski ikan nin pabor. dae ka mag mundo

maski na kutana

+__+ magmademokratiko man sa buko una isi ta man yang kaluwasan nyan. Cgeh masisi sana pag tapos na.

Hinde ah, grabe naman walang patawad

Lovely_Sophie's picture

Hinde ako favor mag karoon ng mina dito sa Catanduanes, Ang mga taong involve dito hinde man lang iniisip ang maging kalagayan ng mga taong maging biktima,.ang nasa isip nila mag payaman. Ang isla Catanduanes lagi dinadalaw ng bagyo ang problema ng mga tao ang,baha ,landslide,.ngayun naman dagdagan naman mining.ano na lang ang mangyayari dun sa lugar ng lagyan ng minahan ,maging kawawa sila dun..puro pahirap naman sa mga taong mahirap. Ang politician dito puro pag yaman ang iniintindi halos yata ng negosyo dito sa kanila kahit saan ka tumigin.inaabuso naman nila ang kapangyarihan.

sorry too :(

jade's picture

Sorry din...salamat sir dave sa pagbago ning boto ko,..kurang pa pano ung aram ko tungkol sa coal mining kaya nagboto muna aq sa undecided pero ninto nakapagbasabasa na aq ning duwagi. grabe paran talga ang epekto ning coal mining..mapalipat man tabi nin boto from undecided to Not in favor..
mabalos tabi..

of course not!

KRISZLE_TEOPE's picture

kasinadit na ngani ng isla, magmimina pa? painano na kaiyan su polusyon, soil, water, air etc?siguro kung idagos yan, ihari ko muna pamilya ko jan sa probinsya. bahala kamu kun magmimina kamo basta uya kami gabos sa harayo.

comelec

ceneth's picture

hala, ano to dadag bawas to ha....lagot kmo ki miriam....hehehe

"i'd rather be RIGHT..............than LEFT.............alone!"

im sorry

eman's picture

im sorry nasala ning boto for i am NOT in favor tabi ako. Sir Dave pakirecall nalng poh ning Boto to. Sorry otro tao lang.hehehe

touch move....

toracks's picture

maboto-maboto....
walang bawian touch move...
baga man sana yan dama....
toracks

hala

man-uukag's picture

hala ka eman, nagboto ka nin pabor hehehe

oi man-uukag

eman's picture

oi man-uukag nasala lang poh ako. Malabog na panu ang mata siguro gagurang na.hehehe

Igwa man poh ako ning PANAWAGAN kay str, sir Dave at sa kung sisay man ang makarecall ning boto plz pakituwangan ako. Nasala lang poh.huhuhuhu

Baging ako ang maluwas sa kontra Bida uya ha.hehehe

recall election, done!

Dave's picture

Ikang eman-eman ka gigibohon mo pa akong taga comelec.... ha ha ha... recall election baga ang apod kaan.

It's done and don't worry at all.

Dave

thank you sir Dave

eman's picture

thank you sir Dave pang 18 ako...

Salamat.hehehe

don't worry

man-uukag's picture

bahala si STR & Dave sa problema mo hehehe

worry not

burabod_bato's picture

eman-eman ka talaga... hehehe

no to MINA

burabod_bato's picture

i am not IN FAVOR OF MINING whatever form it is.....

............

toracks's picture

baad masara ka man nin boto mag pa recall ka... hehehehe
ice men..
toracks